Why tax havens are good

As a tax haven, countries without a more remarkable means of support can become a magnet for international investment and financial and business exchange.

Tax havens are often a win for investors and the community that grows up around servicing those investments. But the opacity of those regional jurisdictions also muddies the view, giving a darker and well-earned reputation that tax havens carry today. Tax havens are an important playing piece in the global game of tax evasion. The loss of tax revenue starves economies of money needed to serve citizens and grow and maintain stable infrastructure.

Taxpayers, legitimate tax-paying businesses, and economies around the world are suffering increased damage from this long-term practice. As well, tax havens, shell companies, and tax evasion are commonly used by terror organizations to fund operations around the world. For existing tax havens, like Ireland and some states in the U. This summer, countries signed on to an initiative that disrupts the way large multinational companies are taxed.

Different tax havens are popular for rebates on different kinds of taxes. But this attribute alone is insufficient to identify a tax haven. Many well-regulated countries offer tax incentives for attracting outside investment but are not classified as tax havens.

This leads to the second attribute of a tax haven. Tax havens zealously protect personal financial information. Most tax havens have formal law or administrative practices that prevent scrutiny by foreign tax authorities. There is no or minimal sharing of information with foreign tax authorities. In a tax haven, there is always more than meets the eye.

The legislative, legal, and administrative machinery of a tax haven is opaque. There are always chances of behind-closed-doors secret rulings or negotiated tax rates that fail the test of transparency.

But that's not all. Tax havens typically do not require outside entities to have a substantial local presence. Such a concession could lead to interesting situations. For example, a Government Accountability Office report found that one building in the Cayman Islands housed 18, mostly international companies.

This suggests that you can claim tax benefits by merely hanging your nameplate in a tax haven. There is no need for actually producing goods or services or conducting trade or commerce within the boundaries of the country. For all practical purposes, tax evaders may continue their business in Florida while claiming to be residents of the Bahamas when it comes to paying taxes. In the end, tax havens are all about marketing.

They promote themselves as offshore financial centers. Many are also considered to be important international financial centers. Other than lower taxes and secrecy, several other socio-economic factors make a particular destination a popular tax haven:.

The Cayman Islands have some of the best secrecy laws, while other countries that also rank high in secrecy and have low-to-no taxes are the British Virgin Islands, Bermuda, Guam, Taiwan, and Jersey. With mounting pressure from international organizations like OECD and the G , tax havens may find it difficult to sustain their carefree existence.

TIEA makes it compulsory to share tax information between signatories and MLAT requires co-operation in matters of legal enforcement and criminal investigations. To make matters worse, some of the tax havens have had to deal with the trouble of their own making. Investors thinking of using tax havens and offshore banking locations should take note of the Liechtenstein banking scandal that shook the world in This scandal came to light when Germany initiated a series of tax investigations based on bank account information sold by a bank technician.

Many citizens of Germany who took advantage of a Liechtenstein-based trust structure for evading tax in Germany found themselves in a noose. The leaked data also put tax evaders in the U.

More recently, the Panama leak has sparked renewed interest and investigations into offshore companies. The existence of tax havens has many effects. At one level, the lower taxes or no taxes in one country put pressure on other countries for keeping their taxes low. This is good for taxpayers in the short term , but the secrecy and opacity associated with some of the tax havens may encourage money laundering or other illegal activities that can harm the world economy in the long term.

The crackdown on tax evaders in some countries shows that taxpayers need to tread with caution. Joseph Manning. Princeton University Press, Ronen Palen. Armando Jose Garcia Pires. A paper by economists Mihir Desai, C. Fritz Foley, and James Hines also finds a complementary relationship between haven and non-haven activity. They found that tax havens indirectly stimulate the growth of businesses in non-haven countries located in the same region.

In line with the literature review mentioned above, their affiliate-level data also reveals that U. These findings suggest that although high-tax countries can lose tax revenue due to profit shifting, tax havens can indirectly facilitate economic growth in high-tax countries by reducing the cost of financing investment in those countries.

Since it published its Action Plan on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting BEPS , anti-tax avoidance measures such as Controlled Foreign Corporation CFC rules , patent box nexus rules , thin-capitalization rules , transfer pricing regulations , and Country-by-Country Reporting have been either implemented or tightened by countries around the world. According to a recent OECD report , these efforts, specifically the automatic exchange of information, have decreased bank deposits in tax havens by 20 to 25 percent over the last decade, a first indicator that tax havens might have become less attractive in the face of anti-tax avoidance measures.

But, as some BEPS measures are still being implemented, it is yet to be seen to what extent they will hinder tax avoidance. As mentioned, eliminating access to tax havens can lead to lower investment in high-tax countries. This can pose a trade-off facing the OECD in tackling profit shifting to tax havens and should be considered in their efforts.

The Tax Foundation works hard to provide insightful tax policy analysis.